Why the Eagles Won't Trade Up for Robert Griffin III

Since Baylor QB and presumed second overall draft pick Robert Griffin III mentioned that he met with the Philadelphia Eagles last weekend, rumors have been swirling around the Internet that the Eagles have a definite interest in the man known as RGIII, and are candidates to trade with the St. Louis Rams and draft him. Members of the media have only fanned the flames; Peter King reported that Griffin III “really enjoyed his time with Andy Reid in the 15-minute interview segment they had,” and John Czarnecki said that he believed “Andy Reid would trade [Michael] Vick straight up for RG3.”

It’s unclear whether the Eagles would actually trade up for Griffin. Heck, it’s not even clear if they’re interested in him; the team regularly meets with all top prospects and underclassmen. I think that in this case, though, the Eagles are at least more than intrigued by Griffin, who has drawn comparison to both Vick and the second overall pick in the 1999 NFL Draft–one Donovan McNabb. Andy Reid is likely salivating at acquiring a prospect of Griffin’s caliber, one who would be the Eagles quarterback for the next decade-plus. From any perspective, Griffin in Philadelphia would be a coup eclipsing last year’s free agent bonanza, one that would make the Eagles a future Super Bowl contender for years to come.

I love RGIII and have ever since I watched the show he put on against TCU in the first game of the 2011 season. I was calling for the Eagles to draft him with their first-round pick back when their season was in the toilet, and his stock hadn’t yet skyrocketed. It will pain me to watch him play us next season, whether as a Brown or a Redskin (and I can only hope it’s the former). Robert Griffin III is going to be an elite player in the NFL for a long time.

But the Eagles can’t draft him. They shouldn’t, and they probably won’t, for a number of reasons.

Let’s start with the most obvious of them; the price is way too high. Using the widespread draft trade value chart, the Rams’ pick is assigned a value of 2600, whereas the Eagles’ first four picks (15, 46, 51, 77) only combine to have a value of 2085, meaning they would have to send a future first-rounder or two more second rounders (assuming, somewhat liberally, that DeSean and Asante have that much value). And that exorbitant asking price doesn’t even take into account two wrinkles: that the new rookie wage scale has made high draft picks even more valuable and the current draft trade value chart obsolete (see here for an explanation), and that the price would also be driven up because the Eagles would have to outbid the Browns and Redskins (according to Howard Eskin, the ‘Skins are already prepared to trade their 1st, 2nd, 3rd, as well as next year’s 1st), as well as any other mystery teams. By the time all is said and done, I expect the Rams to get at least three 1st-rounders for RGIII.

There’s no way the Eagles, who regularly fleece others in trades (see: Kevin Kolb) and pride themselves on their cunningness, are stupid enough to sacrifice so much of their future on one starter, who won’t even play for at least a year. The Eagles have more important positions to upgrade, especially if they plan on gunning for the Super Bowl this year. And all indications are that they must do exactly that.

And that brings up another point: what message do the Eagles send to their players and fans by essentially trading their entire draft for one player? They’d be admitting that the current roster was incapable of making or winning a Super Bowl (which the organization definitely does not believe), and that it was time to rebuild (so why keep Reid, Castillo, and Co.?). Remember, the Eagles have a lot of veteran players whose careers will be on the downswing by the time RG3 is ready to lead Philly to a Super Bowl; getting RGIII really would mean that the Eagles needed to retool to make a future Super Bowl run.

On the other hand, you have a talented roster that is ready to compete for the Super Bowl right now and for the next few years. If you’re running the Eagles, would you rather bring in a few free agents and use your preponderance of high picks to fill the holes and make this team a premier contender, or blow up the roster by staking your future to one player?

The Eagles shouldn’t sacrifice the present to take a chance on the future. They shouldn’t give up on a Super Bowl-caliber roster and turn their backs on their championship window. For all his talent, skill, and potential, they shouldn’t trade away their draft for Robert Griffin III.

And I have faith that the organization believes the same.

Next Eagles Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Jacksonville JaguarsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

  • ZacSnyder

    Very good read, thanks.

  • Pingback: Links to the Best in NFC East Coverage, 2/28 Edition | :: Sparxxrx LLC ::

  • eaglefan

    I agree with only one part of this argument, and that’s the “we’d be giving up our entire draft this year to compete with Washington and Cleveland” one. And even that, I don’t really care so much about, because look at our last couple of drafts (the last two years). With the exception of Watkins and possibly Grahm/Allen (depending if they ever make it back to their pre-injury states), our drafts have blown when we had lots of picks to add impact players to our team. So trading it all away for someone who’d being predicted as NFL ready as Griffin doesn’t seem like a stretch to me. It gives Griffin a year to learn under Vick who plays just like him, and he can come in whenever Vick gets hurt and misses time. And not to compare RGIII to Cam, but look at what Cam did this year with an absolutely terrible Carolina team…I wouldn’t be so quick to say that it would be impossible for RGIII to come in as a second year starter and take us on a run to the playoffs and possibly a Superbowl. If Mark Sanchez could do it with a Jets team that won solely off its defense, RGIII should be able to do it with a far better (overall) Eagles team.

  • Jerky

    Git-R-Done! RG3 for prez

  • Jerky

     @eaglefan Eaglefan, why you no comment wiff the rest of us Eagles fans over at eagleseyeblog.com? Check it out sometime if you like talking Eagles football.