The engine of a great defense should roar like a NASCAR winner at Talladega. Right now, the Philadelphia Eagles' motor has a concerning sputter. It’s not a full breakdown, but that hiccup is loud enough to turn heads in the garage. Everyone is leaning in, listening. They’re all asking the same quiet question about one of the most powerful parts under the hood.
The quiet question just got a brutal, public answer. The topic on Philadelphia’s 94 WIP was the Eagles' shaky defense. Analyst Brian Baldinger did not hold back. "He's been awful. He hasn't made one play. He hasn't shown any violence out there. He doesn't look like he's in great shape," said Baldinger. Jason Kelce defended him. But this is the reality for Jalen Carter.
The $21.8 million defensive tackle is in a brutal slump. And the “bust” talk is creeping from the shadows into the mainstream. His season began with an ejection for spitting. An awful start to the 2025 season after a breakout 2024 show. Then, fines for taunting followed. Now, a heel injury has sidelined him. The stat sheet is barren: zero sacks and zero forced fumbles through four games.
The Eagles felt his absence profoundly. During their loss to the Giants, the defense collapsed. They allowed 172 rushing yards. The interior push vanished. Carter’s $12.8 million dead cap hit feels heavy when he is not dominating. Therefore, this is more than a slow start. This is a crisis of confidence for a cornerstone player.
A Defining Stretch in Minneapolis
Carter, however, declares he is ready. "I’m gonna play this week," he stated. The team desperately needs his presence. Minnesota's offensive line presents a major challenge. This game is a perfect litmus test. Will he be the disruptive force, or will he be a step slow? All eyes are on his every snap.
Retired legend Jason Kelce provided context for this slump. "I always felt like it took me the first four weeks of the season to really feel like I was in football shape," Jason said. He framed this not as a downfall, but as a test of Carter's character. This support is crucial. But ultimately, Carter must answer the bell himself.
The financial implications are massive. His fully guaranteed contract is a long-term investment. The Eagles need a return. Moreover, Vic Fangio’s entire defensive scheme is built on Carter commanding double-teams. Without that, the house of cards tumbles down. This stretch will define his future in Philadelphia.
Read more: Saquon Barkley puts James Franklin on pedestal after Penn State's painful move
So the stage is set. The Eagles fly into a critical matchup. Their defensive identity is on the line. Jalen Carter’s reputation is, too. He must harness his immense talent and fiery passion. The great ones always find a way through adversity. As the astronauts in Apollo 13 understood, failure is not an option.