Tush Push is on death watch after NFL's internal verdict on Eagles' win

Feb 9, 2025; New Orleans, LA, USA; Philadelphia Eagles  quarterback Jalen Hurts (1) lines up for the tush push play on the goal line against the Kansas City Chiefs during Super Bowl LIX at Ceasars Superdome. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
Feb 9, 2025; New Orleans, LA, USA; Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (1) lines up for the tush push play on the goal line against the Kansas City Chiefs during Super Bowl LIX at Ceasars Superdome. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images | Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The Eagles didn’t just beat the Chiefs last Sunday. They dragged them, inch by inch, through the mud of Arrowhead. Both practically and metaphorically. And at the heart of it all? That damn play. The one that looks like a rugby scrum had a baby with a Black Friday stampede. You know the one. The Tush Push. The league’s most hated yard-and-a-half of real estate.

The entire league is obsessed with stopping it. Now, the NFL has quietly admitted what Andy Reid screamed about on the sideline: the Eagles should’ve been flagged. At least once for sure.

The NFL’s internal verdict is in. A league training video distributed after the game confirmed officials missed a false start on a crucial Eagles ‘Tush Push’ against the Chiefs, per a report that first appeared on The US Mirror. The directive to referees seems clear: officiate this play with extreme scrutiny moving forward. And this admission changes everything for Philadelphia.

This puts the Eagles' signature move on a very public death watch. The team’s greatest advantage now has the brightest spotlight shining directly on it. Eagles great Jason Kelce had already predicted what the NFL now said officially.

Kelce noted, “They’re going to be under a microscope moving forward... The calls are going to be starting to come.” This is no longer speculation; it is now policy. Per the video, VP Ramon George stated, “We want to officiate it tight. We want to be black and white and be as tight as we can be when we get into this situation.”

The Eagles have operated in a grey area with surgical precision. Their success rate is a staggering 96.6% on fourth-and-one. This statistical dominance is why 22 teams voted to ban it last May. The play survived by just two votes. This new officiating mandate might just be an eventual method to achieve the same result.

Microscopic Scrutiny Awaits the Eagles' Cherished Tush Push

Coach Nick Sirianni acknowledged the need for perfection. He argued the controversial no-calls were magnified by slow-motion replay. “I think that the one clip I saw of it was slowed down so much that I’m not sure you can see that to the naked eye,” Sirianni said. He later drew a historic NBA comparison to prove his point. But that nuanced view is now irrelevant. And the Eagles’ offensive line now faces an impossible standard.

They must be perfectly still while anticipating a critical snap. Legendary center Kelce warned of this very scenario. Opponents will actively lobby for these flags. Chiefs coach Andy Reid was already frustrated post-game. “If guys are moving early, then you’ve got to call that,” Reid stated. Every future opponent will have this same complaint ready.

The Eagles won’t just be playing the defense on the field; they’ll be fighting a pre-loaded narrative. The Tush Push transformed the Eagles into a relentless converting machine. It was a brilliant exploitation of the rulebook. Now, the league is effectively rewriting the rules in real-time. A single penalty could kill a critical drive. But this is Philly.

Read more: Jalen Hurts confirms who to blame for Eagles' offensive woes

They’ve been hated before. They’ve been flagged, fined, and mocked. And they’ve always responded the same way... by adapting to the situation and giving it back with their performance. Just now, they’ll have to do it without moving a millimeter too soon. The Tush Push isn’t dead. But it’s on life support. And the next flag might just pull the plug.