The Philadelphia Eagles have generally been able to avoid many of the pitfalls other teams fall into during the NFL Draft, but even this organization has a few all-time whiffs.
Some of the worst picks this franchise has ever made include pass rushers that could never get home, wide receivers who struggled with drops, and offensive linemen that played like they were on ice.
These are the 20 biggest NFL Draft busts in Philadelphia Eagles history. Note that this list only counts picks from 1967 onward, as that is the start of the "modern" Draft era.
20 biggest draft busts in Philadelphia Eagles history
20. LB Tim Rossovich, USC (No. 14 overall, 1968)
Rossovich was far from a scrub. In fact, he made a Pro Bowl in his second season with the Eagles. However, the notoriously wild Rossovich, whose pranking exploits included eating glass, setting himself on fire, and jumping off rooftops, burned out quickly. The Eagles parted ways with him after the 1971 season. By 1973, he was no longer a full-time starter.
After brief stints with the San Diego Chargers and the ill-fated WFL's Philadelphia Bell, Rossovich hung up his cleats and transitioned to acting, where he found guest roles on Charlie's Angels and Night Shift. Fun fact: Rossovich's brother Rick became famous on the silver screen for portraying Slider in Top Gun alongside roles in The Terminator and the TV series Pacific Blue.
Passed On: Ken Stabler, Art Shell, Curley Culp
19. DE Mike Mamula, Boston College (No. 7 overall, 1995)
Mamula was one of the first NFL Combine freaks to rise in the rankings solely based on his performance in the underwear Olympics. Mamula would be selected over a quartet of Hall of Fame-level players as the Eagles tried to find someone who could replace legendary pass rusher Reggie White as quickly as possible.
Mamula had a decent career, tallying 31.5 sacks in five seasons and coming in fifth in Defensive Rookie of the Year voting. However, injuries took their toll. After missing all of 1998, his bumps and bruises forced him to retire from the game after the 2000 season. Mamula's athleticism wasn't enough to carry him to pro stardom.
Passed On: Derrick Brooks, Warren Sapp, Curtis Martin, Ty Law
18. CB Ben Smith, Georgia (No. 22 overall, 1990)
Smith may have avoided being on this list had a 1991 knee injury that also forced him to sit out the 1992 season not nipped his momentum in the bud right when he was taking off. After picking off five passes in his first two seasons, Smith recorded just one in the 31 games he played after the injury.
Both the Denver Broncos and Arizona Cardinals (coached by the same Buddy Ryan who drafted Smith in the first place) tried to make him work, but nothing seem to catch on. Eagles fans of that era may wonder what that secondary could have been in the early 1990s with Smith fully healthy.
17. DE/OT Leonard Mitchell, Houston (No. 27 overall, 1981)
Imagine if Nolan Smith struggled so badly in his first few pro seasons that Philly switched him to tight end. That's essentially what happened with Mitchell, as he mustered just one sack in two years before moving to offensive tackle in the 1983 season. Oddly enough, Mitchell was better on that side of the ball.
Mitchell would start 43 games over six seasons in Philly, but using a top pick on someone who never got past the dizzying heights of "basically OK" at a position they didn't even select him to play is a major whiff. Mitchell was traded to the Atlanta Falcons before the 1987 season and was out of football after that year.
Passed On: Mike Singletary, Rickey Jackson, Howie Long
16. WR Freddie Mitchell, UCLA (No. 25 overall, 2001)
Part of the reason the Donovan McNabb-era teams often left some meat on the bone was a lack of pass-catching talent, and the Eagles' investment in Mitchell was one of their biggest mistakes. Mitchell was a smaller receiver who lacked great speed, and it showed when he was on the field.
In four years with the Eagles, Mitchell only tallied 90 catches and five touchdowns while never topping 500 yards in a season. After being released during a 2005 holdout and undergoing some ill-fated tryouts, Mitchell pleaded guilty to one count of conspiring to file a false tax claim with the federal government and was sentenced to 37 months in prison.
Passed On: Drew Brees, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith
15. OG Danny Watkins, Baylor (No. 23 overall, 2011)
Perhaps drafting someone who wanted to be a firefighter instead of a football player and never played the game until age 22 against Canadian university competition wasn't the best idea. Watkins, who was a 26-year-old rookie when he was drafted, never had his heart in football, as he didn't watch film with other offensive linemen. That lack of preparation showed up on tape.
Watkins was benched midway through his second season, and an exceedingly brief one-game cameo with the Miami Dolphins brought about the end of his career. Unsurprisingly, Watkins jumped straight into full-time firefighting after leaving the NFL. Watkins is comfortable doing what he loves, but the Eagles made a seven-figure mistake to find that out.
Passed On: Cameron Heyward, Cameron Jordan, Richard Sherman
14. OT Andre Dillard, Washington State (No. 22 overall, 2019)
Dillard has a reputation as a solid-gold pass protector, but he had some injury concerns that lingered from college. The man Philly drafted to eventually take over for Jason Peters wasn't always healthy, and when he was forced into action, he didn't do much to convince the Eagles to keep working with him.
Dillard would start just nine games in three seasons, and he was less-than-impressive in those nine games. Dillard was beaten out by Jordan Mailata, though that didn't dissuade the Tennessee Titans from giving him a three-year contract in free agency. After 10 starts, Dillard was released, and his life as starter in the pros was over.
Passed On: Maxx Crosby, Deebo Samuel, DK Metcalf
13. WR Jalen Reagor, TCU (No. 21 overall, 2020)
Picking Reagor with Justin Jefferson still on the board didn't make sense then, and it makes even less sense now. Reagor had solid deep speed, but he was unable to run a pro route tree, and having hands of stone also made it tough for Carson Wentz and Jalen Hurts to trust him deep down the field.
The Eagles parted ways with Reagor after just two seasons, 64 catches, and three touchdowns. Unsurprisingly, the Vikings were unable to get him on the right track. Perhaps surprisingly, Reagor is still in the league, as he received a few snaps as a depth option on the Dolphins in the 2026 season.
Passed On: Justin Jefferson, Jonathan Taylor, Xavier McKinney
12. DE Marcus Smith, Louisville (No. 26 overall, 2014)
Smith being picked in the first round was a borderline shocking development for the Eagles, putting even more pressure on Chip Kelly to be right about this selection. His failure is perhaps one of the biggest scouting misevaluations of the Kelly era, if not the outright worst in terms of productivity.
Is starting a whopping zero games in the NFL a bad return on investment for a first-round pick? How about record not just zero sacks as a rookie, but zero tackles? After that nightmare start, Smith four sacks combined over the next two years before being shipped to the Seattle Seahawks and leaving the NFL after two more unproductive seasons.
Passed On: Davante Adams, Derek Carr, Demarcus Lawrence
11. DL Richard Harris, Grambling State (No. 5 overall, 1971)
Harris was once timed at 4.7 seconds in the 40-yard dash at almost 270 pounds, and he managed to put that lightning-quick speed to good use with 7.5 retroactive sack credits as a rookie. Injuries robbed him of most of that quick first step, and the team constantly flipping him between defensive end and defensive tackle also did him no favors. Harris was traded in 1974.
Harris would become a starter for two seasons each with the Chicago Bears and expansion Seattle Seahawks, finishing with 22 unofficial sacks in his career. Harris was a productive player, but not always with the Eagles, though a pre-injuries Harris could have been a genuinely game-changing player. Instead, the Eagles booted the top-five pick in three years.
Passed On: Jack Ham, Jack Youngblood, John Riggins
10. DE Jon Harris, Virginia (No. 25 overall, 1997)
There's no coaching staff subterfuge or injury sob story here; Harris was just a straight-up bad player. A classic tweener who was too slow to be an NFL pass rusher and not strong enough to defend the run on the interior well, Harris recorded two sacks in two seasons while rarely entering the starting lineup.
Harris not only failed to crack the Green Bay Packers' roster after being traded prior to the 1999 season, but his stint of failed tryouts left him unable to secure a spot on NFL Europe's Berlin Thunder in 2001.
Passed On: Jason Taylor, Ronde Barber, Tiki Barber
9. DE Jerome McDougle, Miami (No. 15 overall, 2003)
It's very rare that a Jim Johnson investment up front didn't work out, but McDougle is one of those exceptions to the rule. Injuries and a harrowing incident in which he was shot during an armed robbery of his home set his career off the tracks, but he also failed to reorient things after the initial turbulence.
McDougle, who missed all of 2005 and 2007, finished his Eagles career with just 36 tackles and three sacks on the ledger. A Top-15 pick having that little impact is a major mark against Andy Reid when analyzing his tenure, even if McDougle had many challenges thrown in his way.
Passed On: Troy Polamalu, Jason Witten, Anquan Boldon
8. WR Kenny Jackson, Penn State (No. 4 overall, 1984)
One of three Top 10 picks in consecuctive years that Philadelphia lit of fire, Jackson managed to stick around for seven of his eight NFL seasons. That's fool's gold, however, as he caught just nine passes in his final four seasons. When the Eagles tasked Jackson with fixing the offense, he failed miserably.
Jackson finished his entire pro career with 11 touchdown catches, and he never topped 700 yards receiving in a season. Only once did he top 550 yards. Jackson realized his talents lay in coaching, as he returned to Joe Paterno's Nittany Lions to coach wide receivers from 1993 to 2000.
Passed On: Boomer Esiason, Wilber Marshall, Earnest Byner
7. DT Leonard Renfro, Colorado (No. 24 overall, 1993)
Another Eagles defensive lineman picked in the 20s who flamed out without ever becoming even a quality backup, are you sensing a pattern here? A member of Bill McCartney's legendary Buffaloes team of the early 1990s, Renfro never found a way to get home in the pros.
Renfro mustered just 23 games in the pros, and with 19 tackles alongside an astonishing zero sacks in his time, teams weren't exactly clamoring to bring him in. Rich Kotite and Ray Rhodes may not have been the best evaluators of defensive line talent.
Passed On: Michael Strahan, John Lynch, Will Shields
6. OT Bernard Williams, Georgia (No. 14 overall, 1994)
Mamula, Renfro, and Williams all in a row is a tough sequence. Williams appeared to be a tackle of the future after immediately establishing himself as a starter, but his off-field transgressions led to him getting hit with a ban so strict that he never played in the NFL again.
Williams was suspended from the league after 1994 for violating the league's substance abuse policy, and he never applied for reinstatement. Just like that, his NFL career was over. Williams would play in Canada for a few years, but the Eagles passed on some legends for one average year of offensive line play.
Passed On: Kevin Mawae, Larry Allen, Isaac Bruce
5. QB John Reaves, Florida (No. 14 overall, 1972)
On one hand, Reaves left college as the all-time passing yards leader and a perfect choice to be the Eagles' next star quarterback. On the other, he once threw nine interceptions in a single game against Auburn. The Eagles got the erratic version, as Reaves never even became an established starter for any period of time.
Reaves started seven games in three years as an Eagle, losing all of them while completing 47% of his passes and throwing just seven touchdowns against 17 interceptions. The Bengals brought him in, but his stint in Cincinnati went poorly as well. Reaves retired 4-13 as a staretr with 17 touchdown passes to go against 34 interceptions.
Passed On: Cliff Branch, Lydell Mitchell, Brian Sipe
4. RB Michael Haddix, Mississippi State (No. 8 overall, 1983)
The 1983 NFL Draft was legendary, and the Eagles' reward with a Top 10 pick in this class was a running back who was so slow and inefficient that he holds the NFL record for fewest yards per carry among qualified runners with 3.0 per tote. Haddix somehow managed to stick around in Philadelphia for six years.
In those six season, Haddix never ran for more than 300 yards and ran for three touchdowns. In his final six seasons in the NFL, split between Philly and the Green Bay Packers, Haddix didn't run for a single touchdown. Taking him over multiple Hall of Famers can be called generously called unsightly.
Passed On: Bruce Matthews, Dan Marino, Jim Kelly
3. RB Harry Jones, Arkansas (No. 19 overall, 1967)
Say what you will about Haddix, but at least he hit 100 yards rushing in his career. Jones couldn't even do that. By the end of his four seasons in Philadelphia, the man they called "Light Horse" carried the ball 44 times for just 85 yards (good for 1.9 yards per carry) and was tried out at a few different defensive positions.
Like Jackson before him, Jones found more success as a college assistant. during his time at Pitt, he played a role in helping Hall of Fame running back Tony Dorsett take flight during a legendary collegiate career.
Passed On: Ken Houston, Willie Lanier, Lem Barney
2. RB/S Leroy Keyes, Purdue (No. 3 overall, 1969)
After winning a few meaningless games at the end of the 1968 season, the Eagles were left with Keyes instead of selecting OJ Simpson at No. 1 overall. After running for 361 yards on 3.0 yards per carry as a rookie, the Eagles gave up on him almost immediately, transitioning him to safety.
While Keyes actually managed to have some success as a defensive back, intercepting eight passes in two seasons, the Eagles picked him to be their bell cow running back, and he was nothing of the sort. Mean Joe Greene coming in one pick after him is also a tough twist of fate.
Passed On: Mean Joe Greene, Ted Hendricks, Charlie Joiner
Read more: Put Eagles news on your radar with the new FanSided app
1. OT Kevin Allen, Indiana (No. 9 overall, 1985)
Rather than taking Jerry Rice (likely because they had selected Jackson the prior year), the Eagles took Allen, who is an all-time combination of bad player and bad person. Buddy Ryan gave up on him after four starts, saying he's only useful to "kill grass" and calling him a "USFL reject."
Allen tested positive for cocaine and was released in 1986. Days after his release, he and his roommate were charged with rape. Allen was sentenced to 15 years in prison, though he was released earlier and promptly banned for life from the league. Allen's selection was as bad as it could possibly get on all fronts.
Passed On: Jerry Rice, Andre Reed, Kevin Greene
